THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Neptune City, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated August 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“The Grand Tavern is a culinary gem that serves up exceptional dishes. Their menu features delightful appetizers, including oysters and gem lettuce salad, which boasts a nice crunch from pistachios and bread crumbs. Main courses are equally impressive, with popular choices like halibut, pan-seared to perfection, and snapper. The braised veal dish is a standout, with succulent meat and a savory mushroom stuffing. For dessert, the strawberry shortcake is a must-try, with a moist and dense poundcake and perfectly sweetened whipped cream. With its consistently delicious food and cozy atmosphere, The Grand Tavern is a favorite among foodies and locals alike.”

Customers` Favorites

“Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria is a gem in Neptune City, offering a unique and enjoyable dining experience. The restaurant boasts plenty of parking, except on busy Friday and Saturday nights, and is extremely kid-friendly. The food is a highlight, with pizzas and other dishes impressing visitors. The shrimp co*cktail and chicken cheese steak are standouts, with fresh and tasty ingredients making every bite a delight. With its lively atmosphere and easy seating at the unique Lima bean-shaped bar, this restaurant is a must-visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Blue Habanero Mexican Food is a hidden gem on the road, serving delicious and authentic Mexican cuisine that exceeds expectations. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with friendly staff providing excellent customer service. The quesa-birria tacos and warm chicken salad in taco shell are highly recommended dishes. The birria soupita with cilantro adds a unique touch to the meal, and the generous portions leave customers satisfied. Whether you're in the mood for traditional Mexican flavors or want to try something new, this spot is definitely worth a visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“La Lupa di Roma is a cozy spot for delicious Italian food. The staff is friendly and attentive, making the experience enjoyable. The Pizza Diavola is a favorite among customers, with just the right amount of toppings on a thin crust. The mussels and meatball parm sandwich are also highly recommended. The garlic knots are a must-try, as well as the spaghetti and shrimp. The owner goes above and beyond to accommodate preferences, even customizing dishes. The atmosphere is cozy, with minimal tables, but the food quality makes up for it. Overall, La Lupa di Roma is a hidden gem for those craving authentic Italian cuisine with excellent service.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Caribbean Soul Food Truck offers an authentic and delicious dining experience. The fried fish is perfectly crispy and fresh, while the mac and cheese is homemade and comforting. The owner is an experienced and considerate host, ensuring generous portions of flavorful dishes. This is a highly recommended local favorite.”

Customers` Favorites

“BB.Q Chicken Neptune serves delicious fast food with a variety of flavors. Their food is great, with fantastic chicken and tasty sides. The staff prepares orders efficiently. While the restaurant closes early, their prices are reasonable.”

Customers` Favorites

“Visit It Ain't Just Fish for exceptional food prepared with care, where friendly service and a family atmosphere make customers feel at home. Enjoy generous portions of fresh, delicious meals like catfish nuggets, garlic parmesan wings, and shrimp platters. This popular spot with consistent quality and plenty of options is definitely worth a visit - just be sure to order in advance!”

Customers` Favorites

“Jameson's Southern Cooking is a hidden gem that many people pass by without realizing the delicious food that awaits inside. The overwhelming, intoxicatingly delicious smell of freshly cooked southern food greets you as soon as you enter. The small restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with a few tables to sit down and eat. The owner, extremely respectful and humble, walks you through the menu and specials of the day. The homemade cornbread served with each meal is a delightful addition.The fried chicken and ribs combo meal is a standout, with the best-fried chicken one reviewer has ever had, perfectly crunchy and juicy. The ribs are cooked to perfection, practically falling off the bone and generously sauced with homemade barbecue sauce. Sides like baked macaroni and cheese and mashed potatoes with gravy are also highly recommended.Aside from the delicious food, the homemade carrot cake is a must-try, with one reviewer considering driving an hour just to buy a whole cake. The staff is described as extremely nice and pleasant, creating a welcoming atmosphere akin to being in your mom's kitchen. If you love true Southern cooking, Jameson's Southern Cooking is a place not to be missed.”

Customers` Favorites

“Bruno's Pizza & Subs is the top Italian spot in town, serving up the best pizza and subs. Their Philly Cheesesteaks are a highlight, rivaling those found in Philadelphia. The menu offers a wide variety of specialty pizzas and hot and cold subs at a great price. Don't miss their exceptional chicken parm sandwich, made with high-quality ingredients. With a small parking lot and narrow entrance, be sure to slow down when approaching the building. The friendly staff and delicious food make Bruno's a must-visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Flame Kabob House is a restaurant known for its delicious food, friendly and welcoming staff, and reasonable prices. Located near the sea beach, it offers a super clean atmosphere and an amazing dining experience. The menu features exceptional dishes, including visually appealing platters and perfectly grilled kebabs with mouthwatering seasoning. The mixed gyro platter is a popular choice. Both first-time and returning visitors appreciate the quick and attentive service, making it a great spot for those seeking quality and consistency in their meals.”

Customers` Favorites

“Brewton's Restaurant is a family-run establishment known for its delicious soul food, friendly service, and comfortable atmosphere. A popular choice among locals and visitors, the restaurant offers a great selection of specially prepared dishes, including ribs, shrimp, and sandwiches. The desserts are a highlight, with some reminiscent of home-cooked meals. While the menu prices on the website may not be up-to-date, the food is reasonably priced and well-prepared. The clean and cozy setting makes it an ideal spot for any meal of the day.”

Customers` Favorites

“Shore Good Eats N Treats offers delicious food with friendly service. The Royale burger and 5 cheese Mac & Cheese are excellent choices. Their catering service is top-notch, with a variety of dishes like penne vodka and chicken franchise impressing guests. The Western breakfast wrap is a standout item, and the staff is always welcoming. A hidden gem worth returning to for more tasty meals.”

Customers` Favorites

“Molinari's is a casual and welcoming restaurant that offers a unique BYOB experience. The staff is friendly, and the food is delicious. The menu features a variety of tasty options, including the popular eggplant parm, which is highly recommended. Pizza and wings are also notable dishes. While the restaurant has a nice atmosphere, with flowers on the tables, it's worth noting that there may be bugs present. Additionally, soda refills are charged at $3.50 each, so it's best to order only one.”

Customers` Favorites

“Kelly's Tavern is a classic Irish American bar known for its exceptional corned beef sandwiches and unbeatable Reuben. The staff is praised for their responsiveness and friendly attitude. While it can get loud, the atmosphere is lively and enjoyable. Parking can be tight on weekends. Appetizers like wings and quesadillas are average. This is a great spot for food or drinks, and many customers are regulars. The host, Ryan, is noted for his kindness and helpfulness.”

Customers` Favorites

“Patrick's Grille is a welcoming restaurant that offers a lively atmosphere, warm ambiance, and friendly staff. The menu features a wide selection of beers on tap and innovative dishes. The restaurant is committed to customer service, living by its mission statement "It's an honor to serve you". The food is delicious, with generous portions and reasonable prices. From classic burgers to Prime Rib night on Wednesdays, there's something for everyone. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, Patrick's Grille is a must-stop for a great meal and a pint.”

Customers` Favorites

“Cats Luck offers a wide selection of baked goods, meals, and breakfast options. Their homemade sausage and tofu scramble are particularly noteworthy. The restaurant also offers vegan-friendly dishes like the chick'n and tempeh bacon. Customers can enjoy fresh and dense waffles, as well as delicious peanut butter and cookie dough truffles. The cozy atmosphere includes both indoor and outdoor seating. Many have praised the restaurant's reasonable portions and reasonable prices.”

Customers` Favorites

“Cone Zone is a top-notch ice cream shop with friendly staff and large portions of high-quality ice cream. Customers love the vanilla soft serve with hot fudge and flavors like chocolate chip mint and cherry vanilla. Despite initial doubts, one customer's favorite is the cream and delicious coffee ice cream, and they recommend getting a pint to go for double the deliciousness.”

Customers` Favorites

“Il Posto is a hidden gem that offers an excellent dining experience. The food is fresh and delicious, with vegetarian options like pasta, eggplant, and several appetizers available. The service is attentive and respectful, with a mom-and-pop atmosphere that makes customers feel at home. The prices are reasonable, and the restaurant offers delivery and a quiet atmosphere that is suitable for families with young children. The music adds a lovely touch, and the staff are friendly and welcoming.”

Customers` Favorites

“Santino's Pizza in Neptune is a local favorite, known for its amazing food and friendly service. The menu offers a variety of options, but the Terminator Sub stands out as a customer favorite. The family-friendly atmosphere includes paper tablecloths for coloring and accommodating staff. Located near Avon, it is worth the trip from neighboring towns like Brick.”

Customers` Favorites

“Kamayan Grill is a Filipino restaurant and store located in Neptune, offering a variety of cooked Filipino foods for dine-in or takeout, as well as popular Filipino products for sale. They also provide catering services with medium to large trays of food. The service is friendly and fast, attracting loyal customers from nearby medical facilities. The restaurant has a crowded but exciting atmosphere, with a buffet-style food station offering a range of tasty and well-seasoned dishes. The Adobong Pusit with squid ink is a standout dish available upon request. They also offer baked goods from Christine's Bakery and refreshing boba drinks. While the space is not wheelchair accessible, the abundance of parking makes it convenient for guests. Kamayan Grill is a hidden gem for those seeking authentic Filipino flavors in a welcoming and diverse setting.”

Customers` Favorites

“Dominic's Pizzeria & Trattoria provides fantastic food and great service, even for large crowds. Their garlic knots are outstanding, and calzones/Strombolis, such as the Buffalo chicken and Sicilian Stromboli, are consistently impressive. The pizza is also great, and other menu items like the calamari and chicken cutlet California sub are absolutely delicious. Despite being a takeout-focused restaurant, the staff is patient and provides excellent service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant has been a favorite for many loyal customers. The food is cooked fresh to order, with generous portions and great quality. Specialties like penne vodka w/ sausage, cavetelli w/ sausage in garlic and oil, and chicken francais are popular choices. Despite a rare mishap with a delivered pizza, the overall experience is excellent. The hot sandwiches, salads, and garlic knots are delicious, and the friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere of this cozy establishment.”

“Little Dog Brewing Co. is a quaint local establishment offering traditional, delicious beers. The brewery, which is not dog-friendly, has a cozy atmosphere with 6 beers on tap and a few in cans. The owner provides excellent customer service, sharing knowledge about the beer and area. Fair prices and a welcoming atmosphere make it a great spot to visit.”

“Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard in Bradley Beach is a hit with customers. The young staff are doing a great job and never disappoint. A pregnant customer was grateful for the workers who went above and beyond, providing ice and custard after closing time so she could satisfy her craving for a mango gelati. The kind and accommodating service ensures customers keep coming back for more delicious treats.”

Customers` Favorites

“Luigi's Restaurant & Pizza is a beloved local spot serving delicious food and exceptional service. The restaurant offers a range of dishes, including pizzas, subs, and entrees, all of which are consistently tasty and well-priced. The owners and staff are highly respected and provide top-notch service, going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Whether you dine in or have food delivered, you can expect a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with orders fulfilled quickly and accurately.”

“Arrived and was greeted by the counter/cashier staff member. She took my order promptly. The gentleman preparing my pastrami sandwich confirmed my order since I didn't want any mustard. I had Macaroni Salad and Cole Slaw instead of French Fries. A nice portion of salads and they tasted fresh. An enjoyable sandwich with fresh bread and a nice portion of Pastrami. Wish I had asked for salt and pepper for my salads. I enjoyed a Diet Peach Snapple with my sandwich. I will visit again when in the area.”

Customers` Favorites

“Jersey Mike's Subs offers great sandwiches with fresh and consistent quality, providing excellent service. Despite some mixed reviews on pricing, the overall experience seems positive. The staff is highlighted for their professionalism and handling of difficult customers, making the dining experience pleasant. They offer gluten-free options, although some customers may not prefer it. The restaurant is praised for being kid-friendly, with many enjoying their meals. Overall, Jersey Mike's Subs seems to be a popular choice for a satisfying sandwich experience with friendly service.”

“Carvel is a popular destination for dessert lovers. With a wide variety of treats to choose from, it's easy to get overwhelmed. The staff is professional, pleasant, and helpful, making it easy to make a decision. The ice cream sandwiches are a standout favorite, with one customer even saying they're "absolutely delicious." The atmosphere is peaceful and pleasant, with a convenient and accessible layout. The employees are enthusiastic and engaging, making it a great spot for families. Overall, Carvel is a great choice for a sweet treat.”

Customers` Favorites

“Very good food, I ordered lots of Chinese food and not happy UNTIL House of Fortune! The lady who takes orders is very nice, and I love the service, and the food! This is my number 1 for now. Order from House of Fortune you will be happy. 5 Big Stars! Love the sweet and sour chicken!”

Customers` Favorites

“Great Wall restaurant serves top-quality food that caters to individual tastes. The family-owned business is known for its fast and friendly service, with options for takeout and catering. The menu features popular dishes like sweet and sour chicken, duck, egg foo younga, and wonton soup. While the quality of meals can vary, overall, Great Wall is a reliable choice for Chinese cuisine.”

Customers` Favorites

“Unlike most convenient stores, this store had a very pleasant scent walking through the door, I was gonna get a drink and a snack before school, but I just had to try the pizza there, and my nose wasn't lying. The food tasted good and the boy working there got my pizza just right. Though small and between a rough neighborhood, I'd say it was a diamond in the rough. A well ran and welcoming store for anyone who likes grabbing a snack and bev for the munchies.”

Customers` Favorites

“Maurizio's Pizzeria is a popular spot, often bustling with customers. While the full-size pizzas may not be as impressive, the slices are a standout, with generous portions and a reasonable price. The shrimp scampi slice and rice ball are also notable winners. Service is quick and efficient, and the ambiance is comfortable and lively. With its old-school Italian feel and impressive display of pizzas and calzones, Maurizio's is a beloved spot that's worth a visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“JamaGrille Restaurant & Lounge is a vibrant spot that exudes good vibes only. This BYOB restaurant offers a convenient location with ample parking and proximity to various stores like ShopRite, Dollar Tree, and Target. The atmosphere is welcoming, with a grand opening setup that showcases the owner's dedication. The music selection is on point, featuring hip hop, R&B, Afrobeats, and Club tunes that will keep you grooving. The menu boasts delicious dishes like lemon pepper wings, bang bang shrimp, jerk chicken sliders, and more. The service is attentive and accommodating, with waitresses who go above and beyond. The restaurant has undergone renovations, offering a sleek and modern interior with two floors, including a hookah lounge. Whether you're looking for a spot to catch a game, celebrate a special occasion, or simply enjoy a night out with friends, JamaGrille Restaurant & Lounge is a must-visit destination.”

Customers` Favorites

“Wingstop, a popular restaurant, has received positive reviews from customers. The Neptune, NJ location is particularly praised for its delicious and fresh food, with hot and well-seasoned chicken. The service is described as professional and attentive, with a manager who is dedicated to the restaurant's success. Customers recommend ordering ahead due to potential wait times. The fries and chicken sandwich are specifically mentioned as tasty options. Overall, Wingstop in Neptune, NJ is highly recommended for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Local Smoke BBQ is a restaurant that serves a variety of barbecue dishes, including brisket, ribs, pulled pork, and more. The staff is friendly, and the menu offers a range of options, including mac and cheese, corn bread, and collard greens. While some customers have had positive experiences, others have reported inconsistencies with their orders and average-tasting food. The restaurant offers its own signature sauces and rubs, and the atmosphere can be welcoming. Prices may be slightly higher than expected, but the quality of the food is generally good.”